The 6 Main Challenges of Classroom Gardens (And How to Overcome Them)

Posted by Juan Valdez on February 14, 2017

 

So you want to start a classroom garden...

Classroom gardens can offer new opportunities for students and can be utilized in ways that make them more affordable. 

We’ve already discussed how classroom gardens are a solution to low resources and other benefits. Now we’re going to talk about the first steps toward building your own classroom garden.

2016.05.10.TimMinor.ELL-5279.jpg

This article will help you overcome common challenges of starting a classroom garden, as well as help you find the right materials you need to make it happen. 

Read on... 

Overcoming the challenges of implementation

The most common concerns keeping educators from getting an indoor garden for their classrooms are:

1) Funding

2) Space and facilities

3) Administrative approval

4) Labor

5) Technical expertise

6) Curriculum

If you've been in the education space for long, then you know that there are more and more resources created every day to help educators and their schools overcome these challenges! Here are our tips for jumpstarting those solutions.

 

Funding

Easily the most common frustration for educators hoping to install an indoor farm in their classroom is the issue of funding. Educators often struggle to get the financial resources needed for classroom projects.

Educators don't have to face this problem alone. Numerous foundations, government projects, and federal departments offer resources to teachers in need of funding for projects like indoor farming. These grants usually boil down to three categories:

1) Federal or state classroom/school initiativesGrants.png

These grants are focused on improving nutrition, student health, and educational opportunities nation or state wide. While the alphabet soup of government departments can be intimidating, the paperwork is the most challenging part.

Many of these grants are rarely or never applied for, so even if the amount of funding or description of the project goes beyond the needs of your classroom farm, consider applying anyway.

>> Get more tips on applying for grants here

These grants offer some of the largest opportunities for indoor farming. Some examples include Farm to School and Team Nutrition.

2) Agricultural Initiatives

These grants focus on improving the state of agriculture, empowering local farmers, or improving crop research. While some of these grants might seem to be a bit of a reach for a classroom farm, oftentimes the funding can be reached with a little extra work.

USDA_logo.png

For example, the Specialty Crop Grant focuses on improving the “competitiveness” of a massive list of crops. The grant asks that its awardees improve these crops, and experimenting with hydroponic viability and breeding is certainly a way to improve these crops.

Don’t shy away from some creative language - the worst response you can get from a potential donor is no.

3) Big Box or Commercial

One great classroom funding option educators don't often know about are "Big-Box" store foundation grants. Some "Big-Box" stores are Lowes, Home Depot, Shopko and Walmart.

These stores and others have foundations established which provide grants and other opportunities for people to better their communities - commonly through school programs. Hardware companies in particular make great partners for indoor garden builds.

The companies that provide these grants are looking for public-facing, compelling narratives to help them improve the public’s perception of them. Indoor gardens are both beneficial for the community and make for great press, so don’t hesitate to let these companies help fund your garden.

As with any farming project, teachers should be aware of the continued maintenance and part costs of keeping a hydroponic or aquaponic system functioning. Make sure you're aware of the ongoing costs - start a conversation to make a financial plan by giving us a call at 307-288-1188.

For all of your budget projection and tracking needs, the Able farming tool provides an all-in-one solution. The Able software is tailored to small growing operations and makes managing a commercial farm, our your classroom farm a breeze. Be sure to check out the free software before starting any indoor farming project.

Space and facilitiesspring-in-the-classroom.png

 

How much space does a classroom garden require?

Depending on what sort of farm build (ZipGrow Towers, Farm Walls, Bato buckets, etc.) you’ll be pursuing in your classroom, the space requirements will range from snug farms tucked in the corners of classrooms, to sprawling aquaponic gardens in your school. 

For example, the Farm Wall is a vertical hydroponic garden that takes up about 4-16 square feet when set on the ground. The garden can also be hung on a wall in a classroom or hallway.

Alternatively, a more intensive aquaponic garden may require space for a fish tank and media beds or ZipGrow Towers. That type of garden would need more space; 80-100 square feet is typical.

Other schools have implemented classroom gardens designed to serve the whole school and outfitted full greenhouses anywhere from 200-2,000 square feet.

classroom-garden-space-footprints.png

Want some examples of school gardens? Check out HATponics.

What does a grow space need?

Your grow space will also require water, power, ventilation, and light.

Water: For small gardens, a nearby sink will do. A hose makes labor much easier.   For larger operations, a hose is necessary and drainage is recommended. 

Power: Indoor gardens can function with basic power outlets to run the pump and lights. If you're outfitting a greenhouse with supplemental lighting, talk to an electrician about the power needed to run the lights. 

HVAC-sized.png

Ventilation: If you're building a system more than a few hundred square feet, and especially if the space is tight, you'll need extra ventilation. (If you're building a greenhouse, consider having an expert size an HVAC system for you.)

 

Light: Light is the most underestimated factor of growing. Sometimes a south-facing window is enough light to grow, but crop lifecycles are slower and plants aren't as healthy if they don't have enough light. We highly recommend outfitting your classroom garden with lighting. (You can learn more about artifical lighting in this downloadable guide.)

The team here at Bright Agrotech is happy to help with any estimates of the feasibility of your classroom hosting an indoor farm.

Administrative approval

The real challenge for many educators is securing administrative approval from their superiors.

This issue is very much dependent on the unique circumstances surrounding your classroom. But here are few common stumbling blocks to look out for when approaching your boss for permission to start a classroom garden:

Funding

Be sure to provide a clear, actionable plan that specifies when and how you’ll be paying for the indoor garden. Walk through the major costs of your indoor farm and how they will be recouped through donations, grants, and sales. Have a plan before going to your administrator, so that you can tackle this issue head-on.

Safety2016.05.10.TimMinor.ELL-5302.jpg

Keeping students out of harm’s way is a large concern for the administrators of schools. While most indoor farms only require some basic power, a little water, and decent ventilation, there are risks.

Young students will require supervision around the farm. Electricity and water can present electrical risks. Pesticides and fertilizers each have specific safety recommendations. Most of the safety requirements include simple measures such as wearing gloves and ventilating the space.

To plan safety measures, Google the MSDS sheet for the substance. Common substances used in hydroponics will included calcium nitrate, Chem-gro fertilizers, pH adjustors like pH Down, and pesticides such as Neem and Serenade. 

This is an example of what an MSDS sheet looks like. (Click for the whole sheet.) MSDS sheets include the safety measures required for the substance as well as key information about contents and source.

MSDS-sheet-bleach-screenshot.png

Go to your boss with every safety risk anticipated and a careful plan to ensure the student’s safety.

Favoritism

Unfortunately, many school administrators will be hesitant to allow a project like an indoor farm to proceed because they wish to avoid the appearance of facilitating or favoring a particular teacher. Anticipating this issue can be a simple as creating a basic curriculum that can be shared within teaching groups, classrooms, or cadres of students.

Demonstrate that the farm isn’t just your pet project, but a resource that the entire school can utilize. Emphasize the utility of the farm and the opportunity it affords to all of the faculty in the school.

Labor

Labor is a major hang-up for many educators. A typical American classroom is empty three or four months out of the year. Addressing who will maintain and harvest the indoor farm during these months is an important issue when considering the feasibility of your classroom farm.

Remember that hydroponic gardens can be shut down and started back up fairly easily. Aquaponic gardens house fish that requires maintenance all year long. This is a big factor in deciding which technique to use! If you’re an educator and considering an aquaponic farm, you’ll need to plan for the responsibility of maintaining the farm during the academic off-season.

Consider enlisting parent and student volunteers to maintain the farm during periods where you’ll be unavailable to tend to your crops such as weekends and vacations. Any teacher considering volunteer labor should consider how they’ll train and incentivize these volunteers. Here’s a hint: Delicious vegetables and greens from your farm make a great way to compensate your diligent crew. hatponics.jpg

Technical expertise

Indoor gardens can be both turnkey systems (such as Farm Walls) or DIY projects. Turnkey systems can be put together in an afternoon with basic tools. Hanging artifical lighting can require some carpentry skills and electric drill, but overall these kits are straight forward to set up.

Many educators prefer to build their own system and use the project as a learning experience. This can be an engaging way to teach math, critical thinking, and even business and finance skills.

Creating your indoor garden will take a little technical know-how. Check out our Youtube channel for tips and how-to's on building.  For the more complicated builds, we encourage you to contact the Bright Agrotech team for advice and expertise.

Another great resource for educators is parents and students who might have the tools and technique to get your indoor garden on the road. If you can enlist these valuable workers into your classroom farm team, assembling and maintaining your farm will be much easier. Leverage parent teacher conferences, school newsletters, and student directories to track down the parents that might be able to help with your indoor garden.

Curriculum

How you use your new indoor farm to deliver educational content to students is easily the most exciting and enjoyable part of the building process. You’ll want to have a variety of curriculum options available from the get-go to impress your school administrators and convince them of the need for the opportunity for indoor farming. 

The main question when it comes to curriculum is whether to buy it or build your own.

Building your own lessons

Many educators choose to design their own curriculum. Here are some example lessons for the most common educational topics, aimed at kindergarten through fifth grade classrooms:

Kevin-Savage.jpgOur friend Kevin Savage out of Cincinnati Hills Christian School writes about a botany unit he did with his class using plants grown in the system.

Another sample lesson by Mr. Savage describes a sustainable agriculture class:

“Students used our new PAR meters to measure light intensity at each plant location in the two grow beds of the new hydroponic systems.

"The light intensity data was entered into a data contouring and surface modeling software package called Surfer 13 (Golden Software). Different graphic presentations of the data were created, including contouring showing data locations, contours with color, color 3D surface, and 3D wiremesh."

Learn more about the lessons here.

Another educator, Becky Theis from Lakeview Elementary, connected her indoor garden to the school’s science club. Her club members helped her assemble the planter, harvest the crops, and more. She writes that the most important subject taught was, “Lessons in delayed gratification: many times they wanted to cut the lettuce and start over, but when we were patient, we were rewarded with big, beautiful lettuce leaves!”

Mr. Savage’s and Mrs. Theis’ unique approach to science education is only one of the ways indoor gardens can be leveraged for a meaningful curriculum in your classroom.

Where to get supplies  

Many classroom garden supplies like poly tubing, PVC, and tools can be found at a Lowe's or Home Depot. The actual growing equipment - whether Bato buckets, troughs, or ZipGrow Towers - can usually be bought online. Check out the following links for each type of build to get more information:

Bato or Dutch bucket systems
Aquaponic media bed system
Raft (DWC) system
ZipGrow Farm Walls

Considering another type of system? We're happy to help. Give us a call at 307-288-1188.

If you’re interested in a more formal education on indoor gardening, visit Upstart University for a free trial of the digital classroom service.

Enroll Now

Topics: In the Classroom

New Call-to-action

Subscribe to Email Updates

Focus on the farmer.

Here at Bright Agrotech, everything we do is meant to empower and equip farmers.

Sign up for our newsletter to:

  • Recieve how-to's and info on managing your vertical farm or garden
  • Be the first to know about deals, contests, and giveaways
  • Learn about other gardeners and farmers brightening the future of food.